Wednesday, June 14, 2017

Disrupting Thinking Book Review and Giveaway!

I received a copy of this book for free from Scholastic in exchange for sharing it with my readers. The opinions presented here are purely my own.

My son is two and a half and a voracious "reader." He isn't truly reading yet, but he already has an intense love of books. We read four or five books every night before bed. He requests things like "a hippopotamus book" or "a book about cows" or "dinosaur books" when we head into the library. He can often be found sitting among a pile of stuffed animals or perched atop a mountain of pillows with books scattered all around. He will read aloud to himself by either reciting portions of favorite books he has memorized or by just talking about what he sees on each page. I am thrilled we have successfully instilled a love of reading in him.

I do worry, though, because something is happening to so many kids as they grow up, and I don't want it to happen to him. By the time they reach their freshmen year of high school, they hate reading. One of the greatest frustrations for me as an English teacher and a book lover is when a student is an apathetic reader, meaning they no longer care to read at all. For these students, reading books has lost all meaning.

It is easy to see why our students are losing their love of reading. Reading has become a painful endeavor in the classroom; the standardized testing environment in which we are being forced to teach has managed to suck all of the fun out of reading as we dig and dig to find the answer and we dig deeper to find support for the answer. I imagine you could take any hobby that you love and then pick it apart incessantly until there's nothing left to love. That's what is happening to reading.


What is this product?
Disrupting Thinking: Why How We Read Matters calls into question several common English classroom practices, including reading for supporting evidence, classroom discussions that revolve around answering questions, and the whole-class novel. The premise presented by Beers and Probst is that "disruptive thinking" is the thought that something needs to be better. They provide anecdotes about various inventions and entrepreneurs and how these came about from disruptive thinking and two important questions:

1. What needs to change?
2. What assumptions make that change hard?

This book is ultimately about how we can change common classroom practices that lead to apathetic, frustrated student readers to instead make sure we are helping students become readers who are responsive, responsible, compassionate, and determined.

Beers and Probst say that, if we want to change something ineffective, we must be willing to:
  • Be brave.
  • Accept failure.
  • Be open.
  • Be connected.
  • Get uncomfortable.
This book, divided into three parts, is somewhat backwards designed. Part I focuses on the readers we ultimately want to create, the kind that are responsive, responsible, and compassionate. Part II is where Beers and Probst start getting practical, by offering a framework for building this kind of reader. Part III is where we get uncomfortable as the authors hold up a mirror to common classroom practices and show us how we are killing a love of reading.


The Good and the Bad
Far and away, the greatest takeaway from this book was the BHH (Book, Head, Heart) Framework. This framework encourages readers to think about what was in the book, what is in their heads, and what is in their hearts. Readers are able to respond to a text and provide support for their thoughts, but students are also given the opportunity to explore their own learning as they read and how the reading changes them in some way. The book mentions several other strategies that students can use while reading, but the BHH Framework is definitely the most useful.

Another thing I really liked about this book is the way the authors were able to take a topic (like the BHH Framework) and show how it can be applied across grade levels. I worried that this book would be heavily geared towards upper elementary, the age at which kids start reading to learn instead of learning to read, but I was pleasantly surprised. The authors even had the thoughtfulness to include feedback from college students. I think most of the ideas presented in the book could be applied to any grade level.

The biggest let-down of this book, for me, was the idealism of changing how we do reading in the classroom without truly taking into consideration the current educational climate. It is clear that Beers and Probst are really against all of this standardized testing (I mean, aren't we all?), but ultimately their call to action is a hard one to do. They want us to be brave and open and willing to accept failure, they want us to change the way we teach our readers, but at the same time I felt there was some disconnect between the authors and reality. I agree with them that focused silent reading is probably the best thing a child could do to improve their literacy, and I love the ideas about having students asking the questions instead of answering them... but those things are not as practical when so many teachers have an administration breathing down the backs of their necks trying to boost test scores. I wish that Beers and Probst would have offered some direction for implementing these reading strategies without completely tossing the test-based questions and requirements that we are forced to deal with.


Final Thought
Ultimately, I believe this book is worth any English teacher's time (although the $34.99 price tag is maybe a bit high for what it is). There are some great strategies to take back to your classroom, and the book does have a way of feeling inspirational.

Let's Have a Giveaway!
I have one brand-new copy of Disrupting Thinking ready for one lucky reader! Join the giveaway for your chance to win a copy for free!



a Rafflecopter giveaway

Happy Reading!


15 comments:

  1. I teach science and try to get students reading magazine articles from Discover, Scientific America, etc and have small summary assignments linked to them.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I believe in making difficult material easier by "translating" much of what will be stumbling blocks (Romeo & Juliet anyone?). If I'm excited, they get excited.

    ReplyDelete
  3. We break up large daunting texts into smaller chunks and jigsaw them, so students get practice summarizing. They also get all the important information from the text without feeling overwhelmed by it.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree that the reality of teaching (at least in public school) means that teachers don't necessarily have the freedom to experiment with methods when there's a standardized test hanging over your heads. I learned a reading/comprehension method at a science conference several years ago called RRCU (Read Recall Comprehend Understand - if I remember correctly). It was useful for reading in the content area for short articles.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I was just reading about this book and put it on my summer reading wish list

    ReplyDelete
  6. I agree that the price is high, which is why I haven't bought this book yet. But Bob and Kylene are so knowledgeable and so nice. I've interacted with them on Facebook, Twitter, and in person once (Kylene actually sat and chatted with me for a bit! Fan girl moment!) at a conference for Notice & Note strategies

    ReplyDelete
  7. As a world language teacher (formerly ELA and SS), it is so important for kids to Just Read Out Loud! By hearing what's on the page and each other's voices and inflection, they become stronger, more confident in their reading skills. Of course, so hard to do when class sizes are so big...
    I have this book on my list now, thank you for the review!

    ReplyDelete
  8. My students and I love the Notice and Note strategies for fiction and nonfiction. They feel like they finally have a clearer way of annotating and thinking through a text.

    ReplyDelete
  9. As a new-ish ELA teacher, this issue is something that I'm really thinking about - it's so easy to slide into habits of doing what seemingly prepares students for standardized tests (and is easier to prep...) than to do the really challenging work of figuring out how to get students engaged and thinking for themselves. This sounds worth reading!

    ReplyDelete
  10. I have tried a variety of strategies for reading, but this year, I plan to combine reading with a specific task and annotation together.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Bloody Nora! Four or five books every night!!! It`s cool! I can`t tell the same about me and my children... And of course, it`s true that most students hate reading books till the very end. And if a teacher wants his students to become good readers, it`s important to utilize corresponding methods while teaching it. This article helps to understand some of them. Thanks for your posting. I`ve learned some useful tips as a teacher.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I love using the notice and note strategies with students' self selected text!

    ReplyDelete
  13. I love using the notice and note strategies with students' self selected text!

    [url=https://www.vegas-th.com/gclub.html][color=#ecf3f7]gclub[/color][/url]

    ReplyDelete
  14. Cyber hacking has caused problems for various companies and customers.. protocolhacks{@}gmail. com
    is group of hack team providing help to those who are willing to take the bull buy the horn and SAY NO to online fraudsters
    Have you been into a very long term relationship before or you currently have someone you havnt seen now for days,weeks,months or even years???? beware of scams PROTOCOL HACKS,protocolhacks{@}gmail. com
    we are a team of hackers everywhere on social dating sites,,eradicating and exposing those who call themselves lovers with hidden identities jst to get people scammed,say NO! now and contact us,we solve all problems.Do you need to keep an eye on your spouse by gaining access to their emails,private facebook,whatsapp,skype n many more account? and others to make sure they're not getting into trouble? University grades changing Bank accounts hack Twitters hack email accounts hack Grade Changes hack Website crashed hack server crashed hack Retrieval of lost file/documents Erase criminal records hack Databases hack Sales of Dumps cards of all kinds..
    Our lives are now heavily mediated by technology (emailing, social media, e-banking etc). We are increasingly and often continuously online, open to engagement in a myriad of services and simultaneously open to cyberattack.
    Making sure clients are satisfied. Prices are heavily dependent on the problem you want us to solve

    ReplyDelete